Historian Olivier Richard, who has written several books about Operation Jubilee, shares this opinion. It should have taken place in July but the German planes spotted the fleet. The element of surprise was therefore lost.
Naval support turned out to be insufficient, while air support was struggling against German aviation. In the sky, one of the biggest battles of World War II was being played out. On the ground, guns and tanks struggled to advance on the beach. The crawlers of the tanks were damaged by pebbles and they found themselves trapped by concrete barriers.
On some beaches, the shoreline was particularly steep. Lastly, communication between the troops and military staff was disastrous. Just before 2pm, the weapons went quiet. The day after the raid, those responsible for the operation claimed that — thanks to Jubilee — great lessons could be learned for the rest of the conflict.
For some, it was because of that day in August that V Day was made possible on June 6, This version of events led to the high command being exonerated and the mistakes that had been committed being masked. Ultimately, it stems from accumulated experience, because between and there were also landings in northern Africa and Sicily.
Air support was readily available and a massive British Fleet served as a deterrent of sorts that could protect withdrawing forces. At a tactical level, these types of missions could accomplish specific objectives, such as capturing radar technology or destroying the drydocks and St. At a strategic level, commando operations were great publicity and kept the United Kingdom in the war even though they were no longer on the continent. These raids also forced Germany to commit more resources and troops to defending larger areas, giving the attacking forces the advantage of surprise and flexibility.
Launched on August 19, , Operation Jubilee was a continuation of these tactics. Of the many things that made this raid different, it was the first time Americans would participate in ground combat. Originally conceived as Operation Rudder, the raid at Dieppe was supposed to accomplish a range of missions.
Under tremendous pressure from German forces in the east, Soviet Union Premier Joseph Stalin demanded a second front be opened in the west to divert German war material and troops away from Russia.
Within England, more action against Germany was desired to demonstrate that they were still in the fight. As a result of these various pressures, Operation Rudder grew quickly. Previous raids consisted of a few hundred commandos and Royal Navy personnel; Dieppe would involve 5, British, Canadian, and American landing troops.
Accompanying this dramatic increase in manpower was a grand plan involving parachute drops, infantry battalions, tanks, naval gunfire support, and waves of RAF bombers. The geography of the port of Dieppe was a challenge from the beginning. This section of the French coast is dominated by large, white chalk cliffs. For the majority of this coastline, it is not possible to exit the beach directly onto land. Surrounded by these cliffs, Dieppe sits on the mouth of the Arques River, providing a port and access to the Channel.
Making matters worse for an invading army, the beach is not made of sand; instead it is covered in stones, making it ill-suited for running on, let alone landing heavy equipment. In addition to the geography, the Germans had planned an assault from the sea. Artillery batteries on the high ground around the port supported bunkers, machine gun positions, and anti-tank guns that covered the beaches.
Operation Rudder planned to use a combination of paratroopers and amphibious assault to attack the flanks of Dieppe. This way, the high ground and supporting artillery batteries could be taken before land forces moved into the town. Debate over the merit of the raid continues to the present day. Some believe that it was a useless slaughter, others maintain that is was necessary for the success of the invasion of the continent two years later on D-Day.
Without question, the Raid on Dieppe was studied carefully in planning later attacks against the enemy-held coast of France. There were improvements in the technique, fire support and tactics, which reduced D-Day casualties to an unexpected minimum. The lessons learned at Dieppe were instrumental in saving countless lives on June 6, While individual acts of courage occur frequently during war, only a few are seen and recorded. They stand out as examples for all to admire and respect.
Two Canadians were awarded the Victoria Cross, the British Commonwealth's highest military decoration for bravery, for their actions during the Raid on Dieppe:. Following the landing at Pourville, the South Saskatchewan Regiment made their way toward the town of Dieppe. As they struggled to cross the bridge over the River Scie, Lieutenant-Colonel Cecil Merritt came forward and took charge himself. Walking calmly into the storm of fire on the bridge, he led party after party across by the sheer force of his example.
Other men forded or swam the river. In spite of their valiant efforts, the advance was halted and they were forced to withdraw. Again, Lt. Merritt displayed outstanding courage. Although twice wounded, he commanded a vigorous rearguard action that permitted the majority of the units to successfully re-embark. The rearguard itself could not be rescued, and Lt. Merritt and his men became prisoners of war. The Reverend John W. Calmly, through eight hours of gruelling battle, Reverend Foote, Chaplain of the Royal Hamilton Light Infantry, continually exposed himself to very intense fire to help move the injured to an aid post, saving many lives through his brave efforts.
Then, at the end of this ordeal, he jumped from the landing craft that would have taken him to safety. He walked courageously into the German positions to be taken prisoner, so he could minister to his fellow Canadians who were now POWs.
The hillside cemetery is unique in that its headstones have been placed back to back in long double rows. The Germans buried these war dead, the same way they buried their own. After they liberated the region, the Allies chose not to disturb the graves. Today, the cemetery is maintained by the Commonwealth War Graves Commission.
Some of the captured, wounded raiders died in hospital in Rouen, 58 kilometres away, and 37 are buried in that city. Regimental memorials erected by the survivors and their comrades stand today at all the landing places.
Following the war, the town of Dieppe created a small park at the western end of the esplanade, where it has a memorial of its own. Standing in the centre of Square du Canada Canada Square , the Dieppe-Canada Monument is a testimony to the long and warm association between Canadians and the people of the region, the Normans, which has existed since Samuel de Champlain sailed to found New France.
The names of people and events which have linked Canada and Normandy over the centuries have been recorded on the monument. Mounted on the wall behind it is a plaque that commemorates the Raid on Dieppe:. This regiment was also destroyed. Meanwhile, the Calgary Tanks that did arrive onshore were restricted in their movement, many becoming bogged down by the shingle beach consisting of large pebbles, known as chert.
Some tanks made it into the town, but their guns were unable to destroy the enemy's concrete barriers that lay in their path. The raid was over by mid-day. In nine hours, Canadian soldiers were killed, 2, were wounded, and 1, were taken prisoner. That's more prisoners than the Canadian Army would lose in 11 months of fighting during the Northwest Europe campaign of Fewer than half the Canadians who departed for Dieppe made it back to England. The British lost men killed, wounded and taken prisoner, and there were Allied naval casualties.
In the air battle overhead, the Royal Canadian Air Force lost 13 planes and 10 pilots, out of Allied aircraft and 81 airmen lost overall. Only British commandos, assigned to subdue coast artillery batteries to the east and west of Dieppe, enjoyed some success. And for the Canadians, the day was not without heroism. Honorary Captain J.
Merritt of the South Saskatchewans both received the Victoria Cross , the British Empire's highest award for military valour. Foote, a chaplain, helped care for wounded troops under fire. Merritt bravely led his men over the Pourville bridge and later commanded a rearguard that allowed some troops to escape. Both were taken prisoner. German casualties were light, other than the 48 aircraft lost after the Luftwaffe was drawn into battle. Allied commanders knew the raid was risky.
But none imagined it would be such a terrible failure, with so much loss of life. The planners believed the element of surprise would allow landing troops to overcome German defenders and occupy the town, before withdrawing. Little thought was given to the importance of air superiority and the need for overwhelming firepower, including artillery support from naval warships. The assaulting infantry had only light destroyers firing at the Germans from offshore; no battleships or cruisers were made available for the raid, nor heavy bombers overhead.
0コメント